Analyzing accountability in street-level bureaucracy : managing the implementation of national curriculum statements in the mGungundlovu District of South Africa.
Loading...
Date
2013
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
ii
ABSTRACT
It has become generally accepted among public policy stakeholders, practitioners and scholars
that street – level bureaucrats play a vital role in policy implementation. Because of that, street –
level bureaucrats are attracting considerable interest due to their ability to influence policy
outcomes through the exercise of their professional discretion and autonomy. On the other hand,
there is an immense body of literature covering different techniques public managers can use to
hold street – level bureaucrats accountable. Although many studies have been done to investigate
the role of management in holding street – level bureaucrats accountable, there are very few such
studies in done in South Africa.
Our knowledge of the role of management in holding street – level bureaucrats accountable to
organisational goals in the education sector of South Africa is largely based on very limited data.
The aim of the research was therefore to analyse accountability mechanisms used in managing
the implementation of National Curriculum Statements in the education street - level
bureaucracy of South Africa. The specific geographical unit of the study was uMgungundlovu
District in KwaZulu-Natal Province. The study had five key objectives, each of which is
suggestive of a type of accountability: political accountability, performance accountability,
hierarchical accountability, legal accountability and professional accountability.
In order to understand the different types of accountability used in the implementation of
National Curriculum Statements, a comprehensive review of documents was done. This was
followed by interviews with six high school principals and surveys with 100 high school
educators. The data were analysed quantitatively and qualitatively.
The results from documentary review show that the government was exercising political
accountability in education through various policies as well as financing education. However,
not many respondents were satisfied with its level of political accountability. The results further
show that in line with performance accountability, the government was using performance
measures to in order to hold educators accountable among other reasons. With various levels of
effectiveness, the government is using different forms of hierarchical, legal and professional
accountability mechanisms to hold educators accountable.
The findings of this study have shown that there are various forms of accountability used in the
implementation of National Curriculum Statements. Each type of accountability has its strengths
and weaknesses; therefore, they are not mutually exclusive. The present findings have important
implications for our understanding of the role played by management in managing policy
implementation in street – level bureaucracies.
Description
Ph. D. University of KwaZulu-Natal, Pietermaritzburg 2013.
Keywords
Policy sciences., Government accountability., Education and state--KwaZulu-Natal., Civil service--KwaZulu-Natal., Theses--Policy and development studies.