An evaluation of the effect of mandatory minimum sentencing legislation on judicial discretion in South Africa.
Loading...
Date
2021
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
This research project deals with the effect of mandatory minimum sentencing legislation on judicial discretion in
South Africa, where courts have historically had carte blanche to exercise their considerably broad judicial
discretion when sentencing offenders. This judicial discretion was significantly curtailed by the advent of the
Criminal Law Amendment Act 51 of 1997, and subsequent amendments thereto. The legislation commenced on 1
May 1998 and is still currently in effect. The legislation was enacted in response to an increase in violent crime
at that time, and prescribes mandatory sentences for murder, aggravated robbery, rape, as well as for serious
financial crimes and others. The courts are thought to be contemptuous and repugnant towards this legislation
as it significantly curtails their judicial discretion. Whilst the general public were initially appeased by the impact
of this legislation, many detractors felt this amounted to a harsh sentencing regime, calling for these laws to be
abolished during the 23 years of its operation. This is a qualitative study and is based largely on a critical analysis
of information gathered from the source material in order to identify gaps and trends in the field of interest. The
questions, arguments and debates arising from the chosen focus area are located in both the literature and case
law. The research design utilised is desktop research, which relies on secondary data, which are already in
existence, including government publications, published or unpublished information available from either within
or outside an organization, data available from previous research, online data, case studies, library research,
and the Internet in general. The research will clearly enunciate the current legislative and judicial positions and
advance convincing arguments and viewpoints from an array of distinguished writers and commentators. Various
writers agree that South Africa is in dire need of reforming its sentencing system and believe that mandatory
minimum sentencing has failed to adequately address sentencing problems in South Africa, deter violent crime or
reduce sentencing disparities. They opine that many individuals within the judicial and criminal justice systems
are disgruntled with the current regime, resulting in attempts to circumvent and thus undermine the entire
mandatory minimum sentencing scheme.
Description
Masters Degree. University of KwaZulu-Natal, Pietermaritzburg.
Keywords
Criminal justice, Administration of--South Africa.