Articulating South Africa’s port doctrine for a democratic developmental state.
Loading...
Date
2019
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
South Africa lacks a concise paradigm for port governance. This results in a number of challenges
including lack of cost-based pricing for port services, retrogressive cross-subsidization, inequitable
cost allocation to user groups, siphoning profits from ports to other loss-making divisions of the
transport conglomerate; Transnet’s anticompetitive practices; the port authority’s disregard for the
legislative demand to corporatize and poor port performance relative to the premium tariffs
charged which compromises South African ports’ global competitiveness. These challenges
cannot be satisfactorily addressed without interrogating the socio-political context within which
pricing decisions, tariff structuring and port investment is done and questioning the philosophy
informing these – the port doctrine. With South Africa professing to be a democratic
developmental state, there is no divorcing her political dynamics from government’s strategic
intervention in the ports sector. The socio-political demands and economic and trade objectives
framing the entire macroeconomic strategy have, therefore, to filter down into the ports sector.
This is a PhD by publication with four objectives, addressed through four papers. The study’s
overall objective is to ex-ante articulate a South African port doctrine that translates her
developmental state policies into a doctrine that addresses pricing methodology, tariff structure
and port governance challenges. This study makes prescriptions that account for both historical
context from which port governance emerged and the political convictions of the present and
economic aspirations of the future, all within the paradigm of a democratic developmental state.
Content analysis and document analysis through NVivo 11 Pro® are used to analyze data from
secondary sources. It assesses comments from various port stakeholders concerning the Revenue
Required tariff methodology, tariff structure and the evolutionary changes made to these through
the consultative regulatory process facilitated by the Ports Regulator of South Africa. This study
articulates South Africa’s own port doctrine. The doctrine aligns macroeconomic strategic intents
with port policies and provides a framework for constructing port policy henceforth, gleaning
lessons from some East-Asian states. The proposed doctrine presents a different approach to tariff
methodology, tariff structure and port investment. Lastly, it proposes a port devolution strategy to
achieve increased local private enterprise participation in ports.
Description
Doctoral Degree. University of KwaZulu-Natal, Durban.